|
Scroll down for a table showing
hypothetical results of an investment in the Nasdaq Index from 1972
through 2001 with and without the use of a simple market-timing system.
That timing system, known as the 100-day moving average, is purely
mechanical and can be applied to mutual funds without relying on
judgments, forecasts or analysis. It is designed to capture the bulk of
upward movements during bull markets while protecting assets in a money
market fund during the bulk of bear markets.
Assumptions:
1. NDX 100 index used from 1/3/1990 to 12/31/2001
2. NASDAQ composite used from 12/31/1971 to 1/2/1990
3. Same-Day Trading
4. Commercial Paper Rates are used to simulate money market yields.
5. Fund expenses and management fees are neglected
6. The margin rate is assumed to be 3% above the commercial paper rate.
7. Results are hypothetical.
Used diligently with an aggressive fund, this system is certain to
reduce risk and likely to increase return. Here's how it works: Every
day, calculate the average of the most recent 100 closing prices of the
fund. If the current price is above that average, buy it or hold it if
you already own it. If the current price is below the average, sell it
if you own it. After you sell, park your proceeds in cash until the
price is above the average again.
There's nothing magic about the number of days, 100, except that
it's easy to calculate and a reasonably good tradeoff between tracking
short-term trends and long-term ones.
The table shows year-by-year comparative returns with and without
timing. At its core, here is what the system did: It directed investors
in this index to move to the sidelines 109 separate times and stay
there for a total of about 36 percent of the time during this 30-year
period. The final result was dramatic. Annualized return rose from 11.8
percent without timing to 18.9 percent with timing. That is a huge
difference. An initial investment of $10,000 in 1972 would have grown
to $283,958 without timing or to $1.8 million using this timing system.
The table shows nine measures of risk, and in every one of them,
timing reduced the risk of this investment quite significantly. The
meanings of some of the risk measurements are obvious, but here's a
quick guide to a few that aren't:
-
Standard deviation
is a statistical measure of unpredictability. The higher the number, the wider the variation among annual returns.
-
The worst drawdown
is the largest drop in value from a peak to a bottom that an
investor had to endure in order to stick with this investment strategy
for the entire time.
-
The worst five drawdowns
presents the average of the five largest drops in value. This
figure shows investors what they should expect as a normal occurrence
every five to six years.
-
The Ulcer Index
is a statistical measure based on daily declines. The larger the
number, the more aggravation an investor is likely to experience on a
day-to-day basis.
The trading statistics give some very important data about this
timing system. On average, this system generated about four temporary
investments (each one a purchase followed by a sale) per year. More
than two-thirds of those temporary investments were unprofitable,
likely leading many investors to give up on market timing. Only 31.2
percent of these investments resulted in a profit.
Nevertheless, the timing system was able to multiply the final
return more than six times because the gains were large and the losses
were much smaller. The average gain on the profitable investments was
15.9 percent, while the average loss on unprofitable investments was
only 1.5 percent.
The largest single gain was 71.3 percent, while the largest single
loss was only 5.1 percent. That's why market timing can produce
spectacular long-term results even though it is "right" about the
direction of the market less than one-third of the time.
This study ignored the effect of taxes, which would have reduced the
net return with timing. Future returns and results will be different
from those shown here, and there is no guarantee that this timing
system will work equally well in the future.
Discover how professional money management can help you.
Get a Free Consultation from a Merriman financial advisor. |
|